Story: Other
Author's Note: I wrote this story last semester after reading the acclaimed philosopher Simone de Beauvoir's Second Sex. The characters are based on Simone and her partner, Existentialist philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre. There is a message in mind here in line with some of the ideas that permeate Second Sex, but more than anything I just wanted to write. This is not for Mythology and Folklore, so if you're taking the time to read it anyway, I appreciate it and welcome any feedback!
“Making
itself intelligible is suicide for philosophy” - Heidegger
Shivering, Simone limped out of bed in the
nascent morning to shut the window, marring her fingertips with cigarette ash
that had collected on the sill. She hesitated for a moment, staring longingly
at the crumpled sheets adorning the mattress before picking up a loosely bound
notebook and slipping on shoes.
“Sweetheart,
what are you doing up this early?”
Jean had sat upright and began
fumbling around for his glasses.
“You
look a mess, Simone. Come back to bed, please”.
“I’m
sorry, Jean. I won’t be but a minute. Get some rest, I’ll see you in the
morning.”
Simone slipped into a pale green
jacket and began making her way out of the dimly moonlit apartment, leaving the
bedroom door ajar. Jean let out an exasperated sigh before resting his glasses
on the crowded nightstand and his head on a pillow.
Simone was greeted with the
protesting howls of wind as she took her first steps outside. She lit a
cigarette and began walking aimlessly to the east. Restless nights watching
embers disperse in the breeze were common for Simone. It was a pastime that had
etched sickly yellow into the buds of her fingers and cemented the
contemplative creases on her forehead. Jean detested the smell and the
discoloration of the apartment walls, but never asked Simone to do otherwise.
She thought of Jean as a quaint but decent man. He learned quickly that she did
as she pleased and never once sought to argue on the matter. She had yet to
decide whether she appreciated or despised that quality about him. Under a
dilapidated bus stop shelter at the intersection of two unfamiliar streets,
Simone took a seat on a bench and opened her notebook from the back. Arriving
at a section hastily scrawled on a similar night of insomnia-induced
inspiration, she began outlining objections and scribbling violently through
her perceived mistakes. After a few miserably cold hours, Simone made her way
back to the apartment, threw her jacket atop the bedroom door, and laid her
weary head upon Jean’s chest, who remained steadfast in his sleep.
“Where
is it that we’re going again, Simone?”
Jean hurriedly shaved the unkempt beard from
his face with one hand while combing his hair back with the other. Simone sat
impatiently upon the bed, fidgeting with the buttons of her blouse.
“We’ll
meet Saul in his office and he’ll take us to the lecture hall, remember? No
need to concern yourself with directions.”
“Thank
you, sweetheart. I’m impressed with your resolve. Is there truly no anxiety or
am I just off in my sense?”
Simone let out a light chuckle.
“There’s
nothing I need to worry about at this point, my dear Jean. I’m used to the
process by now.”
Jean stole a kiss from Simone’s red
lips and replied,
“Good, my love. Let’s go, we may still have some time to sit and discuss the fruits of your nightly venture should we walk out the door now.”
“Good, my love. Let’s go, we may still have some time to sit and discuss the fruits of your nightly venture should we walk out the door now.”
“Let
us, then.”
And so, they went.
Simone was in awe of the crowd that
had amassed and taken seat in the grand hall they stood in. Saul’s
introductions brought about a furious roar of applause that inspired her to
take a step forward, hands intertwined with Jean. He looked graciously at her
before stepping ahead and taking his place behind the lectern, placing a
loosely bound notebook down. He waited for the cessation of applause before
sternly looking ahead at the audience.
“What
do we mean when we talk about the Other?”
He began.
Wow, Daegan, the way you have immersed us both in Simone's world with all these sensory details is so powerful, and you also used that special magic of third-person narrative to get us right inside her thoughts moment by moment (like this: "She had yet to decide whether she appreciated or despised that quality about him" ... it's like we are deliberating about that ourselves with her!). I was never a big fan of Sartre, which means I was also a bit dubious about her too, but his story made me feel a great sympathy for her, and wow, what a punch it gives to that final line: “What do we mean when we talk about the Other?” ... I LOVE IT! And listen, it is so cool that you are using this blog to share your other creative work (I saw the poems too!); I'm going to put that in the announcements for the blog stream thing tomorrow, and that way people will see what your are doing. They can use the extra credit blog comments to jump in if they want, and maybe it will also inspire others to do something similar with their blogs; you all could form a kind of creative circle here inside the class, commenting on each other's work. Anyway, we'll see what happens... and for now, thanks for sharing this story: I will remember this story whenever I run into references to Simone de Beauvoir in future. :-)
ReplyDeleteThanks, Laura! I appreciate it!
ReplyDeleteHi Daegan,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your story it gave me that feeling of being a kid again and reading books for AR Tests. I definitely like the use of Imagery in this particular line: "Simone was greeted with the protesting howls of wind as she took her first steps outside. She lit a cigarette and began walking aimlessly to the east. Restless nights watching embers disperse in the breeze were common for Simone". and i like how you were able to connect the reader by taking us into Simone's life. The last line of the story also makes me wonder what the other meant? and also in the first parts of the story where Simone limped out of bed..Was it due to an injury sustained from a past event or was it because of the typical morning feeling of being slightly groggy from waking up in the morning? Lastly, i think it would be better to keep your words a little bit closer together because towards the end it kinda feels a little bit far apart and when i scroll down on my laptop i ended up losing my place a few times. Overall, i think your story is excellent!
The Other is a philosophical concept embodying the opposite of the Self. To Simone de Beauvoir, women constituted the Other and men the Self, wherein cultural roots in patriarchy defined women only in relation to men and thus were the lesser social group. According to Beauvoir, "a man represents both the positive and the neutral, as indicated by the common use of 'Man' to designate human beings in general; whereas 'Woman' represents only the negative, defined by limiting criteria, without reciprocity".
ReplyDeleteThe twist in this story is that we think Simone is going to speak but Jean does instead. In real life, if Jean were to speak of Othering, it would be in a more classically phenomenological sense as opposed to Beauvoir's feminist interpretation. This plot twist exemplifies the concept of Beauvoir's Other as her ideas are utilized (notice how Jean pulls out HER notebook to give the lecture) but her man gets the credit and the acclaim.
I'm really into intersectional feminism theories and feminist philosophy, so I wanted to write a feminist narrative while remaining true to the ennui of the French philosophers and their existentialist ideals. I tried to make their relationship and also this idea-thievery more ambivalent because in real life it is both true that 1) Beauvoir and Sartre had a great relationship with one another full of sexual intrigue and intellectual sparring and 2) Sartre borrowed MANY ideas from Beauvoir's earlier works and utilized them in his writings like Nausea.